Last Day of the Year

theology Comments Off on Last Day of the Year
December 31, 2005

thoughts on science

Uncategorized 3 Comments »

Christoph Cardinal Schönborn pens a very worthwhile article on science in our era. What is noteworthy is how he highlights that Science is speaking beyond itself in many cases, as both the creator and manager of modernity, thus little interested in moving past Positivism. As historians learned a number of years ago, infinitely complex systems are not able to be so easily reduced to sound bites. Thus a humility of perspective sets in which demands that the observer make sure not to go outside of the specific frame of reference.

Curiously, the Church has the same exact problem. It has made a recent history of taking infinitely complex realities and reducing them to broad rules and systematic order. It finally got around to answering modernity’s questions and now has little to say about the questions now being asked, where dualism is not a reality for many people.

I suspect if the Emerging Church ever itself emerges from an anti-establishment liturgical emphasis (called by a friend the seeming obsession with “vodka and oreos”) it will be in a very good position to respond to what is ultimately a pre-Augustinian revolution within the Church that does not separate reality. This is, I believe, the Jewish approach and also the Celtic approach.

It entails a reduction of the intellectualism that has manhandled the faith being replaced with a more lyrical appeal. This isn’t just musical, but lyrical throughout all the various disciplines, making a chorus from the cacophony. Note, that I don’t suggest an anti-intellectualism which raises ignorance as a spiritual quality, but rather a reduction of the insistence that present human reason can fully grasp the nature of God in this world. Modernity despises mystery. Science is the king of modernity so the mysteries which remain it seeks to speak about, even as it drifts in what it really knows. And in speaking from ignorance it has to assert Authority, much as the Church has done for centuries. “Trust us, we know better” both the public Scientist and the hierarchical Church leader have said.

There are other approaches, besided the purely Intellectual, which better address the veils of mystery, and which bypass the intellectual filters in order to best provoke this mystery within our souls. This state of things is likely at the heart of what New Testament scholar Peter Stuhlmacher said a few years ago, “The renewal of the church will not come from academia.”

Strangely, then, this leaves the battle between Faith and Science as argued in much of the Public Square a lot like the Battle of New Orleans. The real war is over, modernity is played out, but the dispatches haven’t gotten to the generals in the field quite yet.

That’s my thought on the subject, now the the significantly more erudite words of Christoph Cardinal Schönborn:

Today, spirit-matter dualism dominates Christian thinking about reality. By “spirit-matter dualism” I mean the habit of thought in which physical reality is conceived of according to the reductive claims of modern science (which is to say, positivism), combined in a mysterious way with a belief in the immaterial realities of the human and divine spirits as known only by faith (which is to say, fideism).

But human reason is much more than just positivistic “scientific” knowledge. Indeed, true science is impossible unless we first grasp the reality of natures and essences, the intelligible principles of the natural world. We can with much profit study nature using the tools and techniques of modern science. But let us never forget, as some modern scientists have forgotten, that the study of reality via reductive methods leads to incomplete knowledge.

Have a go at the Designs of Science.

morning and evening

Uncategorized Comments Off on morning and evening

I’ve lowered the barricades, and unlocked the door. Morning and Evening is open once more, though you might have to squeeze a bit to get in. Watch out for the exposed wiring.

another bird

Scripture, theology Comments Off on another bird

Here’s another bird from my ten minute avian flurry of yesterday morning. I couldn’t quite identify it, so had to ask about. It’s a Yellow-rumped Warbler.

Yellow rumped Warbler

Thanks to the Flycatcher for the help.

change of pace Comments Off on
Walk through the Cross by PDO

Just Because

Scripture Comments Off on Just Because
St. Francis and the Birds

another Mountain Quail

Scripture, theology Comments Off on another Mountain Quail

From a few days ago, a Mountain Quail. For whatever reason, my camera really has a hard time getting a good focus on these birds.

Mountain Quail

Birds of this morning

Scripture, theology Comments Off on Birds of this morning

I spent a bit of time in the living room this morning. The birds of the neighborhood seemed particularly busy. Here’s a selection:
Steller’s Jay

Steller’s Jay

Mountain Chickadee

Mountain Chickadee

Acorn Woodpecker

Acorn Woodpeckers

Acorn Woodpecker

White-Headed Woodpecker

White Headed Woodpecker

White Breasted Nuthatch

White-Breasted Nuthatch


nature Comments Off on ID

A sure sign that a belief system has triumphed over its opponents is that it stops thinking of itself as a belief system at all. Instead it becomes “what every rational person knows to be the case,” or “simple common sense,” or, more concisely still, “the truth.” In other words, the truly orthodox never think of themselves as orthodox. This allows them to crush all dissent to their orthodoxy with a good conscience, since what reasonable objection could there be to sincere attempts to stamp out self-evident falsehoods?

Paul Campos has some words about Intelligent Design.


picture Comments Off on something

Yudhoyono, in a speech marking the anniversary, said the tsunami had afforded a “golden opportunity” to end the conflict and suggested the peace deal was “an example of how a new hope for peace can emerge out of the ruin of destruction.”

After 30 years of fighting the rebels in Indonesia decide the time for war is over. Thanks to the tsunami.